Descendants of Captain Arthur Fenner
Lyman Fenner
[b 30 Sept. 1805 at Adams, Berkshire, MA; d 1841 at Willoughby, Lake, OH] Lyman Fenner m Dorothy “Dolly” Presley [b 26 Aug. 1806 at Seneca, Ontario, NY; d ca. 1842 at Willoughby, Lake, OH], daughter of John Presley and Newey Smith, on 25 Jan. 1827 at Chagrin Falls, Cuyahoga, OH. At one time, Lyman owned 145 acres of property on what is now Lost Nation Road in Chagrin, near the lake. He registered his livestock earmark on 30 Apr. 1840 in Willoughby Township. After Lyman and Dolly both died young, the children were raised by their mother’s sister, Elizabeth “Betsey” Presley, and her husband, William Smith.
Lovina [b 3 June 1827 at Chagrin, Lake, OH; d 29 Jan. 1900 at Chardon, Geauga, OH]. m David Curtiss [b 1816 in CT; d 1882] on 8 Aug. 1847 at Concord, Lake, OH.
Caroline [b 3 Mar. 1829 at Chagrin, Lake, OH; d 24 Sept. 1884 at Copley Center, Summit, OH] m William Caskey [b 1832 at Sharon, Medina, OH; d aft 1880] on 25 Dec. 1868. They had Eledora [b ca. 1862 in IA; d aft 1879] and Arthur F. [b 14 Mar. 1871 at Copley, Summit, OH; d 8 Mar. 1926 in Medina Co., OH] who m Marie A. [b Feb. 1879; d 23 Sept. 1923 in Summitt, OH].
Ann Elizabeth [b 26 Nov. 1830; d 1872 in OH] m Thomas Norman Jr. [b 13 Oct. 1832 in Devon, England; d 5 June 1918], son of Thomas Norman and Sophronia, on 23 Nov. 1865 in Lake Co., OH.
Emily Jane [b 11 June 1834 at Chagrin, Lake, OH; d aft 1899] m Silas Billson [b in NY; d 1883 in OH], son of Peter and Nancy Billson, on 26 Aug. 1852 in Lake Co., OH.
Arthur Quincy [b 20 Dec. 1837 at Chagrin, Lake, OH; d 11 Jan. 1915 at Eustis, Lake, FL] m 1st Catherine Loretta Kaldenbaugh [b 11 Feb. 1839 at Zainesville or Muskingum, OH; d 7 Oct. 1908 at West Mentor, Lake, OH], daughter of Joseph Kaldenbaugh, on 15 May 1859 at Lake Co., OH. Arthur m 2nd Laura Bell Phillips [b ca. 1859 in OH; d 20 July 1935].
Maria [b 17 Aug. 1838 at Chagrin, Lake, OH; d 18 Feb. 1916 near Westmoreland, KS] m 1st George McCargar and had Parmelia [1855], James L. [1856], William T. [1862], and George Alfred [1864]. She m 2nd David Vrooman on 18 Mar. 1866.
Newey [b ca. 1840 at Chagrin, Lake, OH; d 6 Sept. 1846 at Waite Hill, Lake, OH].