Descendants of Capt. Arthur Fenner 

Pardon Fenner

[b 12 Apr. 1809 at Fairfield, Herkimer, NY; d 15 Jan. 1879 at Waukesha, WI] Pardon Fenner was a farmer. He m his cousin Lucy Matilda Fenner [b 25 Aug. 1817 in Chautauqua Co., NY], daughter of his father’s brother Nathaniel, on 11 Sept. 1836. They moved to Waukesha between 1841 and 1849 and worked there as farmers. After Pardon’s death, Lucy went to live with her son Oscar and his family in Deep Well, Hamilton Co., NE.

1. Oliver Gurnsey [b 1837 in NY; d 1870 in WI] m Lucy M. Marsh.

2. Oscar Galatian [b 9 May 1841 at Palmyra, Wayne Co., NY; d 28 Feb 1892 at Grand Island, Hall Co., NE] m Amelia V. Cone.

3. Marcus [b 1849 in WI; d aft. 1870 census].

4. Mary Newman [b 25 Jan. 1851 at Waukesha, WI; d 8 May 1868 at Waukesha, WI].

Lineage:
Arthur | Thomas | Thomas | Daniel | Thomas | William | John | Pardon
Arthur | Thomas | Thomas | Daniel | Thomas | William | Nathaniel | Lucy

Sources:
1. Pardon’s memorial at FindaGrave, no. 53073279
2. Additional data from FamilySearch.